policy

AARP: Wage Inequality Threatens Social Security Solvency as Much as Aging

Summarized from US Top News and Analysis

A new AARP report finds that stagnant taxable payroll growth, not just an aging workforce, is driving Social Security's funding shortfall.

AARP: Wage Inequality Threatens Social Security Solvency as Much as Aging

Social Security's financial troubles stem from more than an aging population, according to new research from the AARP Public Policy Institute. The report argues that the erosion of taxable payroll as a share of the broader economy has played a significant role in shrinking the program's revenue base over time.

Had taxable payroll kept pace with overall gross domestic product, the AARP analysis found, Social Security could continue paying full benefits until 2059 — decades beyond current projections that show the trust funds facing depletion in the mid-2030s. That extended runway underscores how much income concentration at the top of the wage scale has affected the program's finances, since high earners' income above the taxable wage cap goes untaxed for Social Security purposes.

Read more Social Security Funding and Senior Tax Breaks Face Key Decisions →

The findings add analytical weight to policy debates over whether to raise or eliminate the cap on wages subject to the Social Security payroll tax. Proponents of lifting the cap argue it would restore a revenue stream that has gradually narrowed as income growth concentrated among the highest earners. Opponents contend such a change would amount to a significant tax increase on upper-income workers and business owners.

The AARP report reframes a discussion that has long centered almost exclusively on demographic shifts — specifically, the declining ratio of workers to retirees as baby boomers age out of the labor force. By spotlighting the role of wage distribution, the research suggests lawmakers have more policy levers available than previously emphasized when weighing solutions to shore up the program's long-term finances.

Continue reading at US Top News and Analysis.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q.How long could Social Security pay full benefits if taxable payroll kept pace with GDP?

According to the AARP Public Policy Institute, Social Security could pay full benefits until 2059 if taxable payroll had grown at the same rate as GDP.

Q.Why is Social Security facing a funding shortfall beyond just an aging workforce?

AARP research indicates that the shrinking share of taxable payroll relative to the overall economy — driven in part by income concentration above the payroll tax cap — has also contributed to the program's financial gap.

Q.What policy change does the AARP report implicitly support to fix Social Security?

The report highlights the role of the taxable wage cap in limiting Social Security revenue, lending analytical support to proposals that would raise or eliminate the cap on wages subject to the payroll tax.

More in policy →